{ "benchmark": "pglib-uc-warm-start-smoke", "claim_boundary": "Candidate warm-start seed lane is deterministic and Catalyst-Q-compatible. HiGHS rows are real SciPy MILP solves when requested. Catalyst-Q API rows are real SDK/API executions only when execute_api_limit is set. Scale-stress rows show responsiveness when exact MILP baselines fail or hit a timebox; they do not claim global optimality.", "rows": [ { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 522909.456308, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11856, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 42280.285368, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 17570, "case_id": "2014-09-01_reserves_0", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 480629.17094, "objective_improvement_pct": 91.914416, "peak_requirement": 36856.37, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-09-01_reserves_0.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5714 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 379696.14016, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11922, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 42323.925867, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 17612, "case_id": "2014-09-01_reserves_1", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 337372.214293, "objective_improvement_pct": 88.853211, "peak_requirement": 37224.9337, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-09-01_reserves_1.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5690 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 235529.642441, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 12060, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 42337.98529, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 17818, "case_id": "2014-09-01_reserves_3", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 193191.657151, "objective_improvement_pct": 82.02435, "peak_requirement": 37962.0611, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-09-01_reserves_3.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5758 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 181666.102555, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 12212, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 42418.705802, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 18036, "case_id": "2014-09-01_reserves_5", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 139247.396753, "objective_improvement_pct": 76.650181, "peak_requirement": 38699.1885, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-09-01_reserves_5.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5824 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 157879.070019, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11182, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 34722.064122, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15750, "case_id": "2014-12-01_reserves_0", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 123157.005897, "objective_improvement_pct": 78.007177, "peak_requirement": 30479.15, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-12-01_reserves_0.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4568 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 110323.502148, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11212, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 34716.001309, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15848, "case_id": "2014-12-01_reserves_1", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 75607.500839, "objective_improvement_pct": 68.532542, "peak_requirement": 30783.9415, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-12-01_reserves_1.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4636 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 65740.861244, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11286, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 34778.539919, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16010, "case_id": "2014-12-01_reserves_3", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 30962.321325, "objective_improvement_pct": 47.097529, "peak_requirement": 31393.5245, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-12-01_reserves_3.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4724 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 63733.814335, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11352, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 34783.910058, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16178, "case_id": "2014-12-01_reserves_5", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 28949.904277, "objective_improvement_pct": 45.423147, "peak_requirement": 32003.1075, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2014-12-01_reserves_5.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4826 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 58525.906098, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10782, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 28215.150295, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15112, "case_id": "2015-03-01_reserves_0", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 30310.755803, "objective_improvement_pct": 51.790323, "peak_requirement": 26622.95, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-03-01_reserves_0.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4330 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 46313.339997, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10800, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 28118.732789, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15160, "case_id": "2015-03-01_reserves_1", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 18194.607208, "objective_improvement_pct": 39.285889, "peak_requirement": 26889.1795, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-03-01_reserves_1.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4360 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 37019.311583, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10842, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 28212.092218, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15226, "case_id": "2015-03-01_reserves_3", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 8807.219365, "objective_improvement_pct": 23.790878, "peak_requirement": 27421.6385, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-03-01_reserves_3.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4384 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 37487.299336, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10886, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 28243.243295, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15304, "case_id": "2015-03-01_reserves_5", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 9244.056042, "objective_improvement_pct": 24.659168, "peak_requirement": 27954.0975, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-03-01_reserves_5.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4418 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 219274.008471, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11340, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 36681.910532, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16020, "case_id": "2015-06-01_reserves_0", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 182592.097939, "objective_improvement_pct": 83.2712, "peak_requirement": 30020.08, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-06-01_reserves_0.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4680 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 162156.842425, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11376, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 36780.702479, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16088, "case_id": "2015-06-01_reserves_1", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 125376.139945, "objective_improvement_pct": 77.317823, "peak_requirement": 30320.2808, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-06-01_reserves_1.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4712 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 85547.330176, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11452, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 36785.462714, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16254, "case_id": "2015-06-01_reserves_3", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 48761.867463, "objective_improvement_pct": 56.999871, "peak_requirement": 30920.6824, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-06-01_reserves_3.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -4802 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 75852.396875, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11528, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 36833.791937, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 16582, "case_id": "2015-06-01_reserves_5", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 39018.604939, "objective_improvement_pct": 51.440174, "peak_requirement": 31521.084, "renewable_generators": 0, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/2015-06-01_reserves_5.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5054 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 3213519.180079, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 14006, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 136106.422391, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 20038, "case_id": "Scenario400_reserves_0", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 3077412.757688, "objective_improvement_pct": 95.764568, "peak_requirement": 44214.671423, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/Scenario400_reserves_0.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -6032 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 2008667.881886, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 14200, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 140551.586813, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 20258, "case_id": "Scenario400_reserves_1", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 1868116.295073, "objective_improvement_pct": 93.002746, "peak_requirement": 44656.818138, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/Scenario400_reserves_1.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -6058 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 1777710.730633, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 14620, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 164248.711924, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 20614, "case_id": "Scenario400_reserves_3", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 1613462.018709, "objective_improvement_pct": 90.760662, "peak_requirement": 45541.111566, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/Scenario400_reserves_3.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -5994 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 1819192.224873, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 15090, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 261679.279414, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 21122, "case_id": "Scenario400_reserves_5", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 58560, "milp_constraint_count": 87936, "milp_continuous_variables": 29280, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 87840, "objective_delta": 1557512.945458, "objective_improvement_pct": 85.615633, "peak_requirement": 46425.404994, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ca/Scenario400_reserves_5.json", "thermal_generators": 610, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 47761.5, "unit_period_delta": -6032 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 213928573.44962, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 8615, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 89617348.095341, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 13777, "case_id": "2015-01-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 124311225.354279, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.108753, "peak_requirement": 105866.7, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-01-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -5162 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 213928573.44962, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 8615, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 89617348.095341, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 13777, "case_id": "2015-01-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 124311225.354279, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.108753, "peak_requirement": 105866.7, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-01-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -5162 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 238910218.960154, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 9560, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 102362826.513067, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15619, "case_id": "2015-02-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 136547392.447087, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.15427, "peak_requirement": 125155.9, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-02-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -6059 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 238910218.960154, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 9560, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 102362826.513067, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15619, "case_id": "2015-02-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 136547392.447087, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.15427, "peak_requirement": 125155.9, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-02-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -6059 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 251294636.712461, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 9748, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 106472332.62072, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15962, "case_id": "2015-03-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 144822304.091741, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.630479, "peak_requirement": 116644.3, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-03-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -6214 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 251294636.712461, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 9748, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 106472332.62072, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15962, "case_id": "2015-03-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 144822304.091741, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.630479, "peak_requirement": 116644.3, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-03-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -6214 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 205847665.968042, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10952, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 65040732.833564, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15648, "case_id": "2015-04-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": true, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": 264.494, "catalyst_q_api_objective": 65123730.266827, "catalyst_q_api_ok": true, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": "2f9b991cc4877816e06759eab0145006ce8b449d43868a700d9d3d0da3f28606", "catalyst_q_api_status_code": 200, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": true, "milp_highs_available": true, "milp_highs_message": "Time limit reached. (HiGHS Status 13: Time limit reached)", "milp_highs_objective": 71750668.446674, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": 1.889486, "milp_highs_status": 1, "milp_highs_success": false, "milp_highs_unit_periods": 17479, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 140806933.134477, "objective_improvement_pct": 68.403464, "peak_requirement": 101688.1, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-04-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4696 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 205847665.968042, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10952, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 65040732.833564, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15648, "case_id": "2015-04-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": true, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": 230.676, "catalyst_q_api_objective": 65123730.266827, "catalyst_q_api_ok": true, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": "f3847719a140a1a0abc80e80bd1c477cb7f0056308e17552deb24a370f05438a", "catalyst_q_api_status_code": 200, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": true, "milp_highs_available": true, "milp_highs_message": "Time limit reached. (HiGHS Status 13: Time limit reached)", "milp_highs_objective": 71733254.792853, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": 1.543487, "milp_highs_status": 1, "milp_highs_success": false, "milp_highs_unit_periods": 17468, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 140806933.134477, "objective_improvement_pct": 68.403464, "peak_requirement": 101688.1, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-04-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4696 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 186764674.236439, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10147, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 50455454.302502, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 14227, "case_id": "2015-05-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": true, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": 161.127, "catalyst_q_api_objective": 50438380.575364, "catalyst_q_api_ok": true, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": "949fbc02142e1ba53c403255c6dfd92aa76acabb7228f906355cf384776d45ca", "catalyst_q_api_status_code": 200, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": true, "milp_highs_available": true, "milp_highs_message": "Time limit reached. (HiGHS Status 13: Time limit reached)", "milp_highs_objective": 55666078.130278, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": 1.5792, "milp_highs_status": 1, "milp_highs_success": false, "milp_highs_unit_periods": 15878, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 136309219.933937, "objective_improvement_pct": 72.984477, "peak_requirement": 88861.5, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-05-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4080 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 186764674.236439, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 10147, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 50455454.302502, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 14227, "case_id": "2015-05-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 136309219.933937, "objective_improvement_pct": 72.984477, "peak_requirement": 88861.5, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-05-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4080 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 208804369.935857, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11060, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 67009608.972517, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15890, "case_id": "2015-06-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 141794760.963341, "objective_improvement_pct": 67.907947, "peak_requirement": 107030.4, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-06-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4830 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 208804369.935857, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11060, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 67009608.972517, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 15890, "case_id": "2015-06-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 141794760.963341, "objective_improvement_pct": 67.907947, "peak_requirement": 107030.4, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-06-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -4830 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 221549313.342612, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11746, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 77281576.283495, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 17061, "case_id": "2015-07-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 144267737.059117, "objective_improvement_pct": 65.117664, "peak_requirement": 118423.4, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-07-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -5315 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 221549313.342612, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 11746, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 77281576.283495, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 17061, "case_id": "2015-07-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 144267737.059117, "objective_improvement_pct": 65.117664, "peak_requirement": 118423.4, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-07-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -5315 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 240672297.93882, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 12680, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 90467523.882291, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 18489, "case_id": "2015-08-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 150204774.056528, "objective_improvement_pct": 62.410496, "peak_requirement": 128193.2, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-08-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -5809 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 240672297.93882, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 12680, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 90467523.882291, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 18489, "case_id": "2015-08-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 150204774.056528, "objective_improvement_pct": 62.410496, "peak_requirement": 128193.2, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-08-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -5809 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 271240465.275263, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 16686, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 122173073.912181, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 24148, "case_id": "2015-09-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 149067391.363081, "objective_improvement_pct": 54.957652, "peak_requirement": 153190.9, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-09-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -7462 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 271240465.275263, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 16686, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 122173073.912181, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 24148, "case_id": "2015-09-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 93888, "milp_constraint_count": 140928, "milp_continuous_variables": 46944, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 140832, "objective_delta": 149067391.363081, "objective_improvement_pct": 54.957652, "peak_requirement": 153190.9, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-09-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 978, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 177513.27, "unit_period_delta": -7462 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 162970851.693671, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 7342, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 67065139.892955, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 11196, "case_id": "2015-10-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 95905711.800716, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.848384, "peak_requirement": 91171.1, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-10-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -3854 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 162970851.693671, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 7342, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 67065139.892955, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 11196, "case_id": "2015-10-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 95905711.800716, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.848384, "peak_requirement": 91171.1, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-10-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -3854 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 167049757.320754, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 7478, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 69441265.935578, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 11456, "case_id": "2015-11-02_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 97608491.385175, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.430789, "peak_requirement": 95558.2, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-11-02_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -3978 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 167049757.320754, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 7478, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 69441265.935578, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 11456, "case_id": "2015-11-02_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 97608491.385175, "objective_improvement_pct": 58.430789, "peak_requirement": 95558.2, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-11-02_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -3978 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 192381065.467686, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 8132, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 81139568.530718, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 12870, "case_id": "2015-12-01_hw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 111241496.936968, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.823516, "peak_requirement": 103760.901, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-12-01_hw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -4738 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 192381065.467686, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 8132, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 81139568.530718, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 12870, "case_id": "2015-12-01_lw", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 89664, "milp_constraint_count": 134592, "milp_continuous_variables": 44832, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 134496, "objective_delta": 111241496.936968, "objective_improvement_pct": 57.823516, "peak_requirement": 103760.901, "renewable_generators": 1, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/ferc/2015-12-01_lw.json", "thermal_generators": 934, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 180731.71, "unit_period_delta": -4738 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 4819859.050706, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 553, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 4140577.185204, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1068, "case_id": "2020-01-27", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 679281.865503, "objective_improvement_pct": 14.093397, "peak_requirement": 4637.1321, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-01-27.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -515 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 4589764.815326, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 516, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 3889577.441736, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1029, "case_id": "2020-02-09", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 700187.37359, "objective_improvement_pct": 15.255409, "peak_requirement": 4639.5526, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-02-09.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -513 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 4747300.113657, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 532, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 3973899.669312, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1054, "case_id": "2020-03-05", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 773400.444345, "objective_improvement_pct": 16.291375, "peak_requirement": 4457.8503, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-03-05.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -522 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 4531496.788562, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 512, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 3794974.126762, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1019, "case_id": "2020-04-03", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 736522.6618, "objective_improvement_pct": 16.253408, "peak_requirement": 4457.9636, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-04-03.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -507 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 5372828.199499, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 634, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 4773859.51608, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1175, "case_id": "2020-05-05", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 598968.68342, "objective_improvement_pct": 11.148108, "peak_requirement": 5442.6127, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-05-05.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -541 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 6370230.681097, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 888, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 5927207.534759, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1400, "case_id": "2020-06-09", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 443023.146338, "objective_improvement_pct": 6.954586, "peak_requirement": 6772.25, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-06-09.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -512 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 6426541.001724, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 915, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 6043531.175823, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1421, "case_id": "2020-07-06", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 383009.825901, "objective_improvement_pct": 5.959813, "peak_requirement": 6653.5013, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-07-06.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -506 }, { "baseline_feasible": false, "baseline_objective": 7816827.593554, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 457.0212, "baseline_unit_periods": 1553, "candidate_feasible": false, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 7521886.08572, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 457.0212, "candidate_unit_periods": 1892, "case_id": "2020-08-12", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 0, "objective_improvement_pct": 0, "peak_requirement": 8258.0456, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-08-12.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -339 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 5391985.382039, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 635, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 4784256.675775, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1157, "case_id": "2020-09-20", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 607728.706264, "objective_improvement_pct": 11.270964, "peak_requirement": 5769.3802, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-09-20.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -522 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 5034817.229905, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 562, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 4351045.60541, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1093, "case_id": "2020-10-27", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 683771.624496, "objective_improvement_pct": 13.580863, "peak_requirement": 4759.733, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-10-27.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -531 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 4550590.00539, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 516, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 3800470.553142, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1023, "case_id": "2020-11-25", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 750119.452249, "objective_improvement_pct": 16.484004, "peak_requirement": 4568.3384, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-11-25.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -507 }, { "baseline_feasible": true, "baseline_objective": 5321661.476132, "baseline_overgeneration": 0, "baseline_reserve_shortfall": 0, "baseline_unit_periods": 614, "candidate_feasible": true, "candidate_gap_to_milp_pct": null, "candidate_objective": 4723647.245407, "candidate_overgeneration": 0, "candidate_reserve_shortfall": 0, "candidate_unit_periods": 1160, "case_id": "2020-12-23", "catalyst_q_api_attempted": false, "catalyst_q_api_error": null, "catalyst_q_api_latency_ms": null, "catalyst_q_api_objective": null, "catalyst_q_api_ok": null, "catalyst_q_api_response_sha256": null, "catalyst_q_api_status_code": null, "milp_binary_variables": 7008, "milp_constraint_count": 10608, "milp_continuous_variables": 3504, "milp_highs_attempted": false, "milp_highs_available": null, "milp_highs_message": null, "milp_highs_objective": null, "milp_highs_runtime_seconds": null, "milp_highs_status": null, "milp_highs_success": null, "milp_highs_unit_periods": null, "milp_variable_count": 10512, "objective_delta": 598014.230725, "objective_improvement_pct": 11.237359, "peak_requirement": 5053.0255, "renewable_generators": 81, "source_path": "pglib-uc-master/rts_gmlc/2020-12-23.json", "thermal_generators": 73, "time_periods": 48, "total_capacity": 8076, "unit_period_delta": -546 } ], "summary": { "api_case_count": 3, "api_ok_count": 3, "api_selection": "largest", "api_solver": "catalyst-q-api-unit_commitment", "api_success_on_milp_failed_count": 3, "average_improvement_pct": 54.00521, "baseline_feasible_count": 55, "baseline_solver": "capacity-order-warm-start-seed", "candidate_feasible_count": 55, "candidate_solver": "catalyst-q-compatible-merit-order-warm-start-seed-v0", "case_count": 56, "feasible_rescues": 0, "improved_count": 55, "largest_milp_variable_count": 140832, "largest_thermal_generators": 978, "milp_case_count": 3, "milp_failure_count": 3, "milp_selection": "largest", "milp_solver": "scipy.optimize.milp-highs", "milp_success_count": 0, "total_objective_delta": 3162716831.604632, "total_unit_period_delta": -233051 } }